Trunk Economics | December 16, 2024
India’s
E-Commerce Conundrum:
Trade tension and the stakes at home
THE US, NEVER SHY ABOUT expressing its dissatisfaction with the trade practices of other nations, may soon escalate matters with India, threatening tariffs on Indian goods. Such a move could send shockwaves through India’s export economy, jeopardizing livelihoods across the country.
Picture this: India’s local retailers, the economic backbone of the nation, locked in a seemingly unwinnable struggle against multinational retail behemoths. If you think it sounds like a familiar David-Vs-Goliath tale, it’s exactly that—at least if local merchants are to be believed, who say this battle is playing out in India's booming e-commerce space.
The Indian e-commerce market is expected to balloon to $325 billion by 2030, with the digital economy reaching a whopping $800 billion, according to a report by investment promotion and facilitation agency Invest India, driven by increasing internet penetration, low-cost smartphones, and government initiatives like "Made in India" and "Startup India". It's no wonder MNCs are salivating at the prospect of tapping into this lucrative market. But local retailers are crying foul, claiming these giants are muscling in on their territory.
Picture this: India’s local retailers, the economic backbone of the nation, locked in a seemingly unwinnable struggle against multinational retail behemoths. If you think it sounds like a familiar David-Vs-Goliath tale, it’s exactly that—at least if local merchants are to be believed, who say this battle is playing out in India's booming e-commerce space.
So, what's driving the concerns of local retailers? For starters, local retailers say MNCs enjoy unfair advantages like access to cheap capital, cutting-edge technology, and global supply chains. It's like comparing apples and oranges. Local retailers feel like they are being forced to compete with one hand tied behind their backs. They are seeking government intervention to level the playing field. They want policymakers to create a more even playing field, one that allows them to compete fairly with MNCs.
The Indian e-commerce market is expected to balloon to $325 billion by 2030, with the digital economy reaching a whopping $800 billion, according to a report by investment promotion and facilitation agency Invest India, driven by increasing internet penetration, low-cost smartphones, and government initiatives like "Made in India" and "Startup India".
Donald Trump's Re-Election:
A Trade Tension Tightrope
Donald Trump's re-election as US President has India-US trade relations on edge. During his first term, Trump imposed tariffs on Indian goods and terminated India's preferential market access. With Trump at the helm, the US administration is likely to prioritize American business interests, which could lead to increased tensions with India.
The stakes are high, and India must tread carefully. Increasing protectionist policies by India could threaten to upset the delicate balance of international trade relations.
The world watches with bated breath as the US, already vocal about India's trade practices, might retaliate with tariffs on Indian goods.
Imagine a scenario where American companies like Amazon and Walmart are forced to reevaluate their presence in India. The consequences would be far-reaching, affecting not just business but also diplomatic ties. A trade war would deal a devastating blow to India's economy.
To avoid this scenario, India must engage in dialogue with the US and other countries to find mutually beneficial solutions. Clear regulations, transparent and predictable, would ensure a level playing field. By adopting a balanced approach, India can protect local interests while attracting foreign investment and promoting economic growth.
Donald Trump's re-election as US President has India-US trade relations on edge. During his first term, Trump imposed tariffs on Indian goods and terminated India's preferential market access. With Trump at the helm, the US administration is likely to prioritize American business interests, which could lead to increased tensions with India.
The Human Cost of Protectionism
Let's talk about the elephant in the room. Beyond diplomatic fallout and economic losses, there's a human cost to consider. Jobs will be lost, and consumers will suffer as prices rise due to tariffs and trade restrictions. The very people India's protectionist policies aim to protect – small retailers and local businesses – might end up bearing the brunt.
But it's not too late to change course. India must engage in dialogue with multinational corporations, addressing concerns and finding mutually beneficial solutions. Competitive neutrality, rather than stifling competition, would foster innovation and growth. Clear regulations, transparent and predictable, would ensure a level playing field.
The stakes are high, and India must tread carefully. Increasing protectionist policies by India could threaten to upset the delicate balance of international trade relations. The world watches with bated breath as the US, already vocal about India's trade practices, might retaliate with tariffs on Indian goods.
A Balanced Approach:
The Way Forward
So, what's the solution? Competitive neutrality, rather than stifling competition, would foster innovation and growth. Clear regulations, transparent and predictable, would ensure a level playing field. Capacity building for small retailers and local businesses through training and resources would enable them to compete effectively.
Short-term: Implement clear regulations and engage with multinationals.
Medium-term: Gradual reforms and capacity building will be crucial.
Long-term: Establish India as a leader in global e-commerce, promoting sustainable growth and diplomatic cooperation.
The timeline is critical. Here's what needs to happen:
Will India choose protectionism and risk diplomatic fallout, or will it opt for a more inclusive, competitive approach? The world waits with anticipation.
Explore More
-
A FAMILIAR SYMPHONY OF SOUNDS FILLS the mid-morning air in neighbourhood across India. Children’s voices, reciting alphabets, rhymes, and stories, echo from schools, a reminder of the importance of reading in their academic journey.
Read More
-
THE US, NEVER SHY ABOUT expressing its dissatisfaction with the trade practices of other nations, may soon escalate matters with India, threatening tariffs on Indian goods. Such a move could send shockwaves through India’s export economy, jeopardizing livelihoods across the country.
-
Scientific inventions, world history tells us, have been about solving fundamental problems. Think of the printing press.
-
On September 27, the Karnataka government became the first state in the country to come up with a dedicated global capability centre (GCC) GCC policy to attract higher investment in the booming IT sector. The government will establish three new technology parks or Global Innovation District, in Bengaluru and two clusters outside the state capital. Plans are afoot to create 3.5 lakh jobs by 2029.
-
“THE TIME HAS COME FOR policy to adjust,” US Federal Reserve chairman Jerome Powell told an annual symposium for central bankers on August 24.